LIVING IN LA-LA LAND

This afternoon I listened to Paulson and Bernanke answer questions regarding the bailout and alternative solutions to our financial problems. Paulson was asked why he is not giving greater support to Sheila Bair’s proposals from the FDIC. Mr. Paulson’s response boiled down to the fact that he was more interested in saving Capital Markets.

What he forgets is that the failure of the Capital Markets comes from the inability to price Securitized Debt Derivatives because of the failure of the underlying debt which was securitized. This inability to price the derivatives means that their book-value is limited. (Simply, you can’t sell the derivatives because nobody knows if the original debt is good.) Limited book-value means that some of the financial institutions’ capital has vanished.

However, if the underlying debt is somehow guaranteed then the securities would become marketable. If the securities are marketable the markets will establish a price and capital would be restored. This is the approach that Ms. Blair has proposed and Mr. Paulson has pooh-poohed because he believes that it might apply to mortgages but, according to him, it doesn’t apply to what we are facing in the near future.

The future problems facing us have to do with more securitized debt. This time it is in car loans and credit card debt that has been bundled and sold as derivatives. Again, if we find a way to insure the debt, we can stabilize the price of the derivatives and avert a meltdown.

This is where Mr. Paulson is living in La-La Land. He is so close to the capital markets community that he forgets that the USA is a consumer driven economy. He wants to insure the capital markets without addressing the needs of the consumer. However, the capital markets don’t trust the consumer and are raising interest rates and reducing credit limits on credit cards in spite of the capital infusions Mr. Paulson has provided them. Convincing the consumers that they will not face foreclosure and that their debt will be put on a feasible workout schedule is the only way to restore consumer confidence and hopefully increase spending by those with the capacity to do so. Ms Blair’s approach seems to accomplish this goal as well as the goal of stabilizing the prices of the derivatives and should be expanded to other types of underlying debt.